Few things in football are as dramatic and controversial as a players switching allegiance to their club’s biggest rival. Such transfers often spark outrage among fans, leading to burned jerseys, booing in stadiums, and even long-term animosity toward the player. While some have thrived after making these controversial moves, others have faced hostility that overshadowed their careers.
In this article, we explore some of the most shocking and high-profile transfers where players joined their club’s fiercest rivals, analyzing their impact and the reactions they received.
1. Luis Figo – Barcelona to Real Madrid (2000)
The Transfer
- Luis Figo’s move from Barcelona to Real Madrid in 2000 remains one of the most infamous transfers in football history.
- Real Madrid’s president Florentino Pérez triggered his €62 million release clause, making Figo the world’s most expensive player at the time.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Barcelona fans felt betrayed, considering Figo their star player and a future club legend.
- When he returned to Camp Nou, fans threw a pig’s head onto the pitch, symbolizing their anger.
- Despite the hostility, Figo won multiple trophies with Madrid, including two La Liga titles and the 2002 Champions League.
2. Ronaldo Nazário – Barcelona to Real Madrid (2002)
The Transfer
- After an incredible 1996-97 season at Barcelona, Ronaldo left for Inter Milan.
- In 2002, he shocked the world by signing for Real Madrid, becoming part of the Galácticos era.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Barcelona fans were disappointed, but his time at the club was brief, so the reaction wasn’t as extreme as Figo’s.
- Ronaldo became a Real Madrid legend, winning two La Liga titles and scoring over 100 goals for Los Blancos.
3. Carlos Tevez – Manchester United to Manchester City (2009)
The Transfer
- After two seasons at Manchester United, helping them win the Premier League and Champions League, Carlos Tevez joined Manchester City in 2009.
- City even put up a giant “Welcome to Manchester” billboard, taunting United fans.
Reaction & Aftermath
- United fans were furious, seeing Tevez as a traitor.
- He helped City win their first Premier League title in 44 years (2011-12), making the move a success.
- However, his time at City was turbulent, including a fallout with manager Roberto Mancini.
4. Robin van Persie – Arsenal to Manchester United (2012)
The Transfer
- Arsenal’s captain and top scorer, Robin van Persie, made a controversial move to Manchester United in 2012.
- United paid £24 million, and Van Persie guided them to the Premier League title in his first season.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Arsenal fans felt betrayed, considering him their talisman.
- His move ended Arsenal’s title hopes for years, while he became a United hero.
- Despite a strong first season, injuries limited his impact in later years.
5. Sol Campbell – Tottenham Hotspur to Arsenal (2001)
The Transfer
- One of the most controversial moves in English football history, Sol Campbell left Tottenham Hotspur on a free transfer to join archrivals Arsenal in 2001.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Spurs fans never forgave him, labeling him “Judas.”
- Campbell thrived at Arsenal, winning two Premier League titles, three FA Cups, and going unbeaten in the 2003-04 season.
- His legacy remains split—a legend at Arsenal, hated at Tottenham.
6. Gonzalo Higuaín – Napoli to Juventus (2016)
The Transfer
- Higuaín was adored in Naples, breaking Serie A’s goal record in 2015-16.
- In 2016, Juventus triggered his €90 million release clause, making him the most expensive Serie A signing at the time.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Napoli fans burned his jerseys and cursed his name.
- Higuaín won three Serie A titles with Juventus, but never fully regained Napoli’s love.
- The move intensified the rivalry between Napoli and Juventus.
7. Zlatan Ibrahimović – Inter Milan to AC Milan (2010 & 2020)
The Transfer(s)
- Zlatan played for Juventus, Inter Milan, and AC Milan, making him one of the few players to represent all three Serie A giants.
- He left Inter for Barcelona in 2009 but returned to AC Milan in 2010.
- After a stint in the USA, he rejoined Milan in 2020, helping them win Serie A in 2021-22.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Inter fans felt betrayed, but Zlatan remains respected for his undeniable talent.
- AC Milan fans welcomed him as a club legend for his role in their resurgence.
8. Andrea Pirlo – AC Milan to Juventus (2011)
The Transfer
- After a decade at AC Milan, Andrea Pirlo joined Juventus on a free transfer in 2011.
- Many saw this as a mistake by Milan, as Pirlo went on to revive his career at Juve.
Reaction & Aftermath
- AC Milan fans were disappointed but didn’t direct hatred toward him.
- Pirlo won four straight Serie A titles and became a Juventus legend.
- This transfer is regarded as one of the best free transfers in football history.
9. Cesc Fàbregas – Barcelona to Chelsea (2014)
The Transfer
- After leaving Arsenal for Barcelona in 2011, Cesc Fàbregas made a shocking return to the Premier League in 2014—but to Chelsea instead of Arsenal.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Arsenal fans felt betrayed, especially as he helped Chelsea win the Premier League.
- He became a key playmaker at Chelsea, winning multiple trophies.
- Despite his success, Arsenal fans never fully forgave him.
10. Fernando Torres – Liverpool to Chelsea (2011)
The Transfer
- In January 2011, Fernando Torres left Liverpool for Chelsea in a £50 million deal, a British transfer record at the time.
Reaction & Aftermath
- Liverpool fans were devastated, as Torres was one of their beloved stars.
- He struggled at Chelsea, never reaching his Liverpool peak.
- However, he scored a crucial goal in the 2012 Champions League semifinal, helping Chelsea win the title.
Conclusion
SUGGESTED FOR YOU
The Best Women’s FIFA World Cup Moments in History
Switching to a fierce rival is one of the biggest risks a player can take. While some, like Luis Figo and Robin van Persie, found success and silverware, others, like Fernando Torres, struggled under the pressure.
For fans, these moves ignite emotions and fuel rivalries, ensuring that football remains as dramatic off the pitch as it is on it.
What Do You Think?
Which of these transfers shocked you the most? Let us know in the comments!
